Advertisers:
advertise on this site

Steve Clemons Moderates a Discussion on the Future of Al Qaeda

Steve Clemons facilitates discussion amidst New America Foundation's Al Qaeda 3.0 Conference, featuring Frances Townsend, Bruce Hoffman, Steve Coll, and Peter Bergen

Steve Clemons on the Washington Journal

Steve Clemons discusses the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and what an Obama administration's foreign policy might look like, October 23, 2008

Steve Clemons and Ambassador Husain Haqqani on the State of Play in Pakistan

Pakistani Ambassador to the United States Husain Haqqani analyzes the domestic political scene in Pakistan and discusses how the United States can work with the new government to promote stability and security in the region.

More videos are available on the Video Archives Page

The Washington Note is now a member of the Political Insiders advertising network:
Find out more...

VA Loan and VA Refinance
Information from VA Mortgage Center



ADVERTISE SEND FEEDBACK OR TIPS CONTACT DETAILS
Support The Washington Note

Using PayPal

Looking for Comedy in the Muslim World: Albert Brooks' New Film Fails

Share / Recommend - Comment - Print - Wednesday, Jan 11, 06, 10:46PM

CLOSE  
SOCIAL WEBSITES
Digg
Del.icio.us
Reddit
Facebook
Newsvine
Stumble Upon
EMAIL THIS ARTICLE


Email addresses will not be stored

oakshades2.jpg

At least, Oakley wears his sunglasses outside.

When I went to see Looking for Comedy in the Muslim World this weekend at a Regal Cinemas event hosted by the Center for American Progress, actor and director Albert Brooks wore his sunglasses in the theatre.

I really wanted to like this film. I tried hard. The peer pressure was intense.

Seated around me were very luminescent luminaries and some semi-luminescent ones. Some were just normal folks out to watch the flick for free.

Paul Begala was there. John Kerry and former Senator Fred Thompson, who also appears in the movie, sat a couple of rows in front me. David Brock seemed to enjoy it, though I'm not sure he really did. I just heard him say that he liked it but it could have been just what he needed to say to get out of the room. John Podesta was the host. Even Grover Norquist was there.

I've hosted Washington, D.C. film premieres in the past for the policy crowd -- for Thirteen, Kinsey, In America, and Gunner Palace -- but I always insist on seeing the film before I screen it. I don't require that the film necessarily be "great", but I feel I need to be able to pitch it to 'my audience' in a way that permits honest discussion and debate about the respective policy issues raised.

After Thirteen, which starred Holly Hunter and was directed by Catherine Hardwicke, the Economist devoted a full "Lexington Page" to the event and the complicated family and teenage issues.

The way Looking for Comedy was presented, it sort of constrained honest discussion rather than opened it up. However, Brooks did say that the film got more intense support when he showed it in Dubai.

But with all due respect to Albert Brooks and the Center for American Progress, this film -- which I think many progressives will find themselves trying to like -- is a counterproductive movie.

Brooks told us that he made this film about looking for comedy and humor in the Muslim world to try and make the case that movies need to start addressing (again) the world we find ourselves in today. He said that the leading films of the year like Brokeback Mountain, Goodnight and Good Luck, Capote, and others were period pieces set in the past. He said that the complexity of our times was making us look back -- rather than to the present, or even the future.

Brooks has a point.

However, without giving away anything I probably shouldn't about the film -- the two "types" of humor that Brooks depicts working in the Muslim world are "stupid pet tricks" and "Jewish jokes." In one particularly bizarre seen, Al Jazeera tries to recruit Brooks for a new comedy sitcom that it is appearing for its new (fictional) Al Jazeera E Channel called "That Darn Jew."

I walked out of the theatre near a group of Muslims who were in the audience -- and in barely audible whispers and quiet commentary -- they were furious with the film.

What's odd is the premise of the film. I happened to attend a "Christmas Party" that was also a farewell luncheon hosted by the London Al Jazeera office when I was last in the U.K. -- and hung out with various staff from Egypt, Tunisia, Algeria, Syria, Jordan and other places, and their humor was way better than mine -- and this movie's (. . .and Al Brooks' -- at least in this film).

I don't really like coming down hard on this movie as I generally like Brooks, and I have been involved in the past with movies that were controversial and not considered to be great successes either. I was the "talk show host" and technical advisor on the Sean Connery/Wesley Snipes film Rising Sun -- but that's a topic for another year.

But the way to reach the Muslim world, or to get Americans to break through the tension that they may feel about our problems there, is to get beyond the caricatures of bad Jewish jokes and silly animal tricks.

There's very rich humor in the Middle East. I showed this recently when I hosted Yosri Fouda of Al Jazeera at the New America Foundation. Not only was he a thoughtful and articulate observer and commentator about the Muslim world and terrorism issues, but he can be hilarious.

John Kerry, Paul Begala and the rest all looked quite satisfied with the film, but as anything in Washington or Hollywood, appearances can be deceiving.

And what really bothered me is that the film could have been great and might have been a vehicle that "humanized" the Middle East and helped Americans gain more insight into the "lighter" side of Muslim life.

-- Steve Clemons

Reader Comments (13) - post a comment

Posted by Greg Priddy Jan 12, 12:39AM - Link

Steve,

I remember thinking, when I opened the email invite from CAP -- that this could be either very well done, or very poorly done, but it won't be in between... and probably the latter. I had other plans that evening, but it sounds like I didn't miss much...

By the way, sort of off topic, but still on the Middle East -- I'd be curious to hear your views at some point on the recent developments on the nuclear issue in Iran.

Posted by larakatt Jan 12, 2:37AM - Link

Brooks is funny, but he is a horrible actor and visually unpeasant to me, lumpy and bland like plain oatmeal. He should stick to writing and directing and leave the acting to actors.

Posted by Jacob Matthan Jan 12, 8:02AM - Link

Bending over backwards to accommodate a community is the worst that one can do.

People are people and there is no need for such a show unless there is guilt.

And America has a lot of guilt, so some "Liberals" seem to want to create a bridge.

Treat a person for what he shows himself to be, not on a preconceived notion.

Posted by CKR Jan 12, 9:29AM - Link

None of this would have been a surprise to anyone who saw the previews of the film.

Posted by Volansky Jan 12, 10:14AM - Link

steve,
i've been anxious to see this film since the article in "variety" appeared last march. i'll take a look-see with your thoughts in mind.
and i sometimes wear my sunglasses indoors -- does that make me as cool as oakley?
love,
mv

Posted by Frank Sinatra Jan 12, 10:44AM - Link

So let's see, you and John Kerry sit down for an evening of film watching with Grover Norquist, one of Bush's principal aiders and abettors outside of the government. You shouldn't even be content to walk the same planet as this man, much less socialize with him. If you and all the other so-called progressives in this town would live up to your convictions and shun him and all the other reactionary jerks that infest this town, they wouldn't get away with nearly as much trash as they do. I've said it before and I'll say it again: this is just another example of how ridiculously incestuous things are in DC. How do you expect to oppose someone when you're cozying up to him?

Posted by Abu Musab al-Sarcastic Jan 12, 12:10PM - Link

Steve, how about 'looking for comedy in Oakley's world'? Brooks is an idiot. How much comedy is to be found in genocide, apartheid, and mindless slaughter? How much comedy is to be found living in abject filth tucked neatly inside an Israeli concentration camp? That is the plan for the West Bank, wall it off and let the Palestinian people die in their own squalor.
Yup, sounds like real comedic material to me.

Posted by Laura Jan 12, 1:03PM - Link

Too damn bad if muslims were furious over the film. If only they would be furious over beheadings perpetrated by their own people among other atrocities. No, that barbarism doesn't infuriate them, what infuriates them are movies and cartoons. And typically western leftists seek to pander to the muslims oh so fragile sensibilities. Meanwhile the muslims own media features the most vile anti-Semitism, anti-American, anti-western rhetoric. muslims have no sense of humor anyway, so how do you expect them to respond.

Posted by Bud Jan 13, 1:51PM - Link

Steve,

Did the film make people laugh? That's the bottom line for all comics and most viewers. If the film makes me laugh out loud a number of times, I will be pleased. Humor and political agenda rarely mix well.

Posted by SevenOneEight Jan 13, 2:57PM - Link

I was at this event and the only person I recall cozeying up to Grover was Steve Bing, one of the film's producers.

Interestingly, I did hear from a reliable source that Norquist's wife is Pakistani (she did not appear to be in the theater). I suspect that had a lot to do with his attending an event sponsored by CAP.

I do agree with Steve, the film is a failure and not worth seeing unless you happen to find it on cable late at night during a bout of insomnia.

Posted by chris from boca Jan 13, 3:50PM - Link

my quick review: didn't actually see it, but have to admit that all sides have a point. wish to be fair and balanced in my opinionating: want to comment; wouldn't be prudent.

Posted by SevenOneEight Jan 15, 6:57PM - Link

Correction: Grover's wife is Palestinian NOT Pakistani as I wrote in my previous post.

Posted by SevenOneEight Jan 15, 6:58PM - Link

Correction: Grover's wife is Palestinian NOT Pakistani as I wrote in my previous post.

The Washington Note - Steven ClemonsHome - About - Archives - Published - Recommended - Advertise - Contact
THIS SITE IS COPYRIGHT © 2008 THE WASHINGTON NOTE. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.