Advertisers:
advertise on this site

Steve Clemons Moderates a Discussion on the Future of Al Qaeda

Steve Clemons facilitates discussion amidst New America Foundation's Al Qaeda 3.0 Conference, featuring Frances Townsend, Bruce Hoffman, Steve Coll, and Peter Bergen

Steve Clemons on the Washington Journal

Steve Clemons discusses the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and what an Obama administration's foreign policy might look like, October 23, 2008

Steve Clemons and Ambassador Husain Haqqani on the State of Play in Pakistan

Pakistani Ambassador to the United States Husain Haqqani analyzes the domestic political scene in Pakistan and discusses how the United States can work with the new government to promote stability and security in the region.

More videos are available on the Video Archives Page

The Washington Note is now a member of the Political Insiders advertising network:
Find out more...

VA Loan and VA Refinance
Information from VA Mortgage Center



ADVERTISE SEND FEEDBACK OR TIPS CONTACT DETAILS
Support The Washington Note

Using PayPal

Jeremy Kahn: The Politics of Gesture

Share / Recommend - Comment - Print - Tuesday, Jun 06, 06, 1:24PM

CLOSE  
SOCIAL WEBSITES
Digg
Del.icio.us
Reddit
Facebook
Newsvine
Stumble Upon
EMAIL THIS ARTICLE


Email addresses will not be stored

Granted, more than 90% of communication is supposed to be non-verbal. And images and atmospherics certainly are as important to diplomacy as the spoken and written word. But if Sunday's much-discussed New York Times tick-tock on how the Bush administration came to its turnabout on engagement with Iran is true, the Bush administration seems to have raised non-verbal politics to a new and disturbing level, both inside the White House and abroad. For starters, here is how The Times describes the luncheon between Rice and Bush that set the administration on the path toward offering to talk to Iran:

A meeting [Rice] had attended in Berlin days earlier with European foreign ministers had been a disaster, she reported, according to participants in the discussion. Iran was neatly exploiting divisions among the Europeans and Russia, and speeding ahead with its enrichment of uranium. The president grimaced, one aide recalled, interpreting the look as one of exasperation "that said, 'O.K., team, what's the answer?'"

That body language touched off a closely held two-month effort to reach a drastically different strategy, one articulated two weeks later in a single sentence that Ms. Rice wrote in a private memorandum.

This is somewhat bizarre. You would think that on a topic of such importance, Bush might express an opinion rather than forcing his advisers to guess at the meaning of his facial expressions. Maybe attending meetings with the president is a bit like going to a farm auction, in which guests are cautioned against making any extraneous gestures lest they be inadvertently end up buying a cow. ("Condi, did you just suggest we bomb Tehran or were you just scratching your nose?")

Further evidence of Bush's apparent fascination with non-verbal communication is offered later in the Times story, this time in an international context:

The idea intrigued Mr. Bush, White House officials say, and on May 8, Ms. Rice met with him just hours before flying to New York for a meeting with her European counterparts.

She asked him what kind of body language to display at the United Nations meeting. Should she signal that the United States was considering negotiations with Iran? "Be careful," he said, according to officials familiar with the conversation. "I haven't made up my mind."

I wonder how Rice tried to follow the President advice? Did she raise her left eyebrow while speaking? And I wonder if the diplomats at the UN correctly guessed at the subtle significance of Rice's body language? In international diplomacy, when one is dealing with people from different cultures and backgrounds, I think it would be helpful, even more so than in a domestic context (where certain gestures are universally understood within the social context), to send unambiguous signals. And, if one wants to avoid unnecessary misunderstandings, this is probably best accomplished through deliberate words and actions -- not smiles and grimaces.

Jeremy Kahn is managing editor at The New Republic.

Reader Comments (1) - post a comment

Posted by Hydrocodone Aug 27, 3:00PM - Link

Welcome to Great Blog here!

Leave a comment:


(required)
(required)
- only for verification, not for display or any other use.

(required)

Type the characters you see in the picture above.


The Washington Note - Steven ClemonsHome - About - Archives - Published - Recommended - Advertise - Contact
THIS SITE IS COPYRIGHT © 2008 THE WASHINGTON NOTE. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.