Advertisers:
advertise on this site


Steve Clemons interviews Eli Pariser

Former Executive Director of MoveOn.org, Eli Pariser discusses his new book "The Filter Bubble" and how the architecture of the internet is evolving to match our interests and filtering out information that might challenge our opinions.

Steve Clemons on Obama's Approach to Libya

Steve Clemons argues that in addittion to being ineffectual militarily, a no-fly zone will change the narrative of the Libyan uprising and shift the focus from the decisions of the Libyan rebels to the actions of Western nations.

Ian Bremmer On the War Between States and Corporations

Eurasia Group President Ian Bremmer discusses the political and economic impacts of the economic recession, as well as rising economic powers.

More videos are available on the Video Archives Page

The Washington Note is now a member of the Political Insiders advertising network:
Find out more...

VA Loan and VA Refinance
Information from VA Mortgage Center



ADVERTISE SEND FEEDBACK OR TIPS CONTACT DETAILS
Support The Washington Note

Using PayPal

Launching Le Cercle Lafayette

Share / Recommend - Comment - Print - Saturday, Aug 12 2006, 12:27PM

lafayette.gif

Completely independently of my recent post acknowledging France's diplomatic maneuvers in securing UN Resolution 1701 calling for an end to the violence between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon, I have agreed to help organize a new U.S.-France group of public affairs and policy intellectuals called Le Cercle Lafayette.

With the enthusiastic support of French Ambassador Jean-David Levitte, we will be launching this new group at the Ambassador's home September 6th on what is Marquis de Lafayette's 249th birthday.

I need to read up on Lafayette, whose important role and contributions to America's independence and its history I know in thin form. I know we have some revolutionary era officianados reading this blog, and I'd appreciate any notes or materials that might bring Lafayette and a contemparary appreciation for his role to life.

More later.

-- Steve Clemons



« Previous Article - The Diplomacy Prize Goes to France This Round
» Next Article - Beating Terrorism: It's the Grievances, Stupid

Reader Comments (51) - post a comment

Posted by MP, Aug 12 2006, 1:06PM - Link

Steve: Should we all write in French on this thread? Qu'en pensez-vous?

Posted by Patrick McGill, Aug 12 2006, 1:08PM - Link

How do we get invited to that?

Posted by Linda, Aug 12 2006, 1:40PM - Link


What wines and cheeses are you serving? French or California?

Posted by un autre Etienne, Aug 12 2006, 1:43PM - Link

Alors, je suis tres heureux que Etienne (nos "Steve") est a la tete d' un nouveaux "salon" qui est consacre a la formation de milleur relations entre les communautes, Francais et Americain, et j'espere ils pouvent arrete le plonge a Armageedon et bois beaucoup de bon vin et mange exquisite si le situation est trop fou et le fin est certain. Embrassez, tous baisez!

Posted by elementary teacher, Aug 12 2006, 2:17PM - Link

MP,
J'ai signalé une réponse à votre question dans le fil précédent. Merci bien.

Posted by Steve Clemons, Aug 12 2006, 2:19PM - Link

To The Other Etienne --
Many thanks for the wonderful note. I will need to take up French but find that Google Translation works pretty well. On the guest list, it's closely held -- but will let you know how Le Cercle Lafayette evolves.

Best,

Steve

Posted by Carroll, Aug 12 2006, 3:52PM - Link

Marvelous idea!...

Most of my reading on the Revolution has been mainly about the South's part...but I do know Lafayette was what you could honestly call "a rebel's rebel"...a real adventurer. From a wealthy noble family who bought his own ship and sailed to America. There is a town not far from me in NC named after Lafayette's homeplace in France, La Grange.

I know he fought with Washington at Valley Forge and I think maybe at Yorktown too.. he was the one responsible for getting France to send aid to the colonies fight.

I tried to remind my congressman, Jones, of this when he had french fries renamed freedom fries. Interestingly enough, I called the French embassy during the France bashing to apologize for my politicans and the embassy said they had received many of the same type calls so not everyone in this country is a total imbecile.

Drink more French wine and sell Louisiana back to France, maybe they can do something with it.

Posted by elementary teacher, Aug 12 2006, 4:16PM - Link

Carroll, Hey.

One teeny weenie caveat: it's about the wine, hon. I do live in wine country (Southern) California. It's called Temecula. The vineyards are all around me, peek over my back fence, you're at a winery.
If TWN's Carroll & The Posters (sounds like a 1950's rock group) are ever out this way, kindly remember: (a)do look me up, pretty please, and (b) at our winery, you drink local.
As I live and breathe...

Posted by Keith, Aug 12 2006, 4:22PM - Link

Although he died 172 years ago, the Marquis has his own website - www.marquisdelafayette.net - which has links to many articles and collections. There is a great deal of information at Cleveland State University.

Posted by Carroll, Aug 12 2006, 4:29PM - Link

Dear elementary teacher ...

I have been to Calif. wine country, it's beautiful out there..and I confess I drink some Calif. wines....I do think some of them are equal to some French wines...but the best of French wines are still the best!

NC has some wines too..but to tell the truth they are pretty awful..every year I have a friend who gives me Duplin and Biltmore wines at a Christmas party...I always insist on opening them and "sharing" with everyone right then so I won't have to take too many home..LOL.

Posted by km4, Aug 12 2006, 4:31PM - Link

Steve, are you having French or Freedom fries at the Ambassador's home September 6th ?

Posted by calvinthecat, Aug 12 2006, 4:49PM - Link

calvin, being an aging cat, no longer has total recall, but does seem to remember some French phrases, like:

"Lafayette, nous sons arrivee."

Does anyone else plugged in here recall it's significance?

Posted by elementary teacher, Aug 12 2006, 5:25PM - Link

calvinthecat,

From what I could dig up General Pershing is said to have declared upon his arrival in France during the First World War, "Lafayette, we are here!" (Lafayette, nous voilà!), suggesting that the United States was repaying its debt for his assistance during the Revolutionary War. However, this attribution is apocryphal, and was actually said by Lieutenant Colonel Charles E. Stanton at the tomb of La Fayette, in the cemetery Picpus in Paris,
July 4, 1917.

Posted by Marcia, Aug 12 2006, 5:48PM - Link

Je recommande aussi la lecture de la correspondance entre Montaigne et La Boétie, qui se prénommé Etienne. Tous deux étaitent déjà préoccupés par les mêmes questions que celles qui nous torturent aujourd'hui, les abus de pouvoir de l'état et les penchants des peuples à se jetter dans les bras de tyrans.
A ceux qui passent des examens on dit "Merde" pour leur souhaiter bonne chance.
My ancestors were in all the wars, Revolutionary, 1812, Civil, on both sides, I had friends whose ancestors paid others to go in their place. Perhaps they were related to the Bush and Cheney gang. We have often had discussions as to whether they were smarter or just richer. The world of ideas never stops turning.

Posted by elementary teacher, Aug 12 2006, 6:16PM - Link

Marcia, Je suis également fasciné avec les écritures de La Boétie, se rapportant à elles pour placer des dilemmes courants dans le contexte plus profond de l'histoire des idées.

Posted by Pissed Off American, Aug 12 2006, 6:50PM - Link

Speaking of revolution, Newt Gingrich just called Anti-war Americans "insurgents" on Fox News. We are now seeing fascism here in its purest form. I ask you, as "insurgents" are we now subject to being termed "enemy combatants" as well? Is this the rhetoric of tomorrow, that will justify Bush rounding up his detractors and holding them incognito and without judicial oversight? As we look outwards towards France, towards Lebanon, towards Iraq we are forgetting the war we should be waging HERE to save our own democracy.

Will YOUR vote be counted in November?

Posted by cm, Aug 12 2006, 8:18PM - Link

Le Cercle Lafayette is later referred to as La Cercle Lafayette.

You were right the first time.

Posted by Peter Eggenberger, Aug 12 2006, 8:20PM - Link

It's a very small point, but "cercle" is a masculine noun. The group should be called Le Cercle Lafayette.

Posted by MNPundit, Aug 12 2006, 8:27PM - Link

According to Wikipedia's entry, Lafayette was that rare person who when he had power, was not corrupted by it he was not a particularlly good general, he was not a particularly good politician, but he always seemed to fight for those Revolutionary ideals. An interesting guy Lafayette.

Posted by bakho, Aug 12 2006, 10:12PM - Link

Matt Stoller is on board for the next Bolton fight. Interesting take:

http://www.mydd.com/story/2006/8/12/205819/682

Posted by Liam Shortall, Aug 12 2006, 10:48PM - Link

vive le france

Posted by mike, Aug 13 2006, 12:29AM - Link

Lafayette, whose full name was Marie Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier, would have been a fascinating character even if he had never come to America. He is quoted by Burke Davis who has a great book on the battle of Yorktown as saying: "The moment I heard of America, I loved her; the moment I knew she was fighting for freedom, I burned with a desire of bleeding for her."

But Lafayette got all the press, so please do not neglect some others from France who fought beside Washington:

* General Rochambeau along with French infantry regiments, cavalry troops, and and an artillery battalion. Many of these died fighting alongside Americans at Yorktown and were buried in Virginia soil.

* Admiral de Grasse along with 22 French warships. Many of his sailors and marines died fighting the British fleet at Cape Henry just off the mouth of the Chesapeake bay and were buried at sea in American waters.

Posted by Maude, Aug 13 2006, 8:59AM - Link

This is great, Steve.
It's about time the French were honored for standing by the American people even when our government is hostile to them.
The French are saving lives by getting a cease fire.
I used to be fluent in French, but not now.
I was in Paris when they were burning the American flag over Viet Nam.
Any book book on the French/Indian war is helpful.
France was right about Iraq.
We can learn a lot from countries that have gone through the imperialism phase and know the folly of it.
Maude

Posted by jeff roby, Aug 13 2006, 9:53AM - Link

Jeff Shaara paints a fascinating picture of Lafayette in one of his Revolutionary War novels, The Glorious Cause. Yes, it's a work of fiction, but is well-researched and has a ring of truth not gotten from "scholarly" sources.

Posted by Hedley Lamarr, Aug 13 2006, 10:27AM - Link

Today we are called insurgents. How long before aWol & Co. get us on the no-fly list?

Posted by Leonard, Aug 13 2006, 10:50AM - Link

Steve,

Simon Schama's history of the French Revolution, Citizens, uses the figure Lafayette as a touchstone throughout, beginning with his relationship with George Washington in America.

One of the more recent studies on Lafayette and America is Lloyd Kramer, Lafayette in Two Worlds: Public Cultures and Personal Identities in an Age of Revolution.

For background on the vital French role in winning the War of the American Revolution, see William Stinchcombe, The American Revolution and the French Alliance, the essay collection edited by Ronald Hoffman and Peter Albert, Diplomacy and Revolution: The Franco-American Alliance of 1778, and the scholarship of Jonathan Dull, esp. A Diplomatic History of the American Revolution.

Good luck with this project.

Posted by Joker to the Thied, Aug 13 2006, 11:46AM - Link

I would personally recommend this book "Sister Revolutions: French Lightning, American Light" by Susan Dunn.
As a teacher of English in (Pars) France, I find your project very interesting. My (American) friend and I, we have actually been trying to build bridges between our two nations in all sorts of ways and I'd be curious to follow your project... and maybe help if needed be.
Joker-to-the-Thief.

Posted by Regis, Aug 13 2006, 2:03PM - Link

My wife and I visited LaFayette's grave in the Picpus Cemetary in Paris several years ago. It remains a highlight of many trips to Paris. The setting and history associated with the cemetary, in addition to it being the burial ground of LaFayette and his wife's family, make the cemetary a must-see for those with an interest in LaFayette as well as The Terror.

Posted by Mark Horton, Aug 13 2006, 3:08PM - Link

Interesting topic. You can think of the French, during our Revolutionary period, like the Iranians of the current crisis in Lebanon. France officially denied that they were helping our forefathers in any way. When the British showed captured French weapons, intelligence, and even French (ex)military officers, still the French government claimed no responsibility. It would almost be comical how inter-country diplomcy functions until you remember that real people are dying as a result of the actions or inactions of diplomats and politicians.
Steve, I applaud your interest in the history of this period. I just hope in the one month of your "reading up" on the subject that you will be able to go beyond the outer skin material so prevalent in our 'modern media'.

Posted by lebedeb, Aug 13 2006, 7:52PM - Link

Just saw the 60 minutes Mike Wallace interview with Iran's President Ahmadinejad and he was wonderful, a real nice guy, laughing, joking and talking sense. The whole interview will be on C-SPAN tomorrow evening. Watch, you'll love the guy and wish you could love your President as much.

Cheers

Posted by Fred, Aug 13 2006, 8:27PM - Link

Interesting and this triggers youthful memories. I grew up in and around Camden, S.C. and went to Baron DeKalb school in my early years. When we moved into town we lived on Lafayette St. which ran alongside the county courthouse where the Lafayette Cedar still grows. This tree was, I believe, planted by Lafayette when he was in Camden. I will be back over there in a couple of weeks and will take a photo of the tree and the monument. I also haven't visited the site of the Battle of Camden in decades so I may run up there since my 90+ old great-uncle lives near the battle site.

Posted by L. Heart, Aug 13 2006, 8:52PM - Link

Quote:

This is great, Steve.
It's about time the French were honored for standing by the American people even when our government is hostile to them.


__________________________

Reply:
This is intended as sarcasm...right???

Posted by L Heart., Aug 13 2006, 8:53PM - Link

Quote:

Just saw the 60 minutes Mike Wallace interview with Iran's President Ahmadinejad and he was wonderful, a real nice guy, laughing, joking and talking sense. The whole interview will be on C-SPAN tomorrow evening. Watch, you'll love the guy and wish you could love your President as much.

Cheers

_____________________

Reply:

This is also intended as sarcasm...right????

Posted by Daniel, Aug 13 2006, 11:07PM - Link

I had the honor and the pleasure of meeting Ambassador Levitte at a private talk he gave in summer of 2003 in Santa Monica at RAND. During the talk he told us that he was the president of the UN Security Council on September 11, 2001. He described some of what transpired in the UN that day and that week. Many of his comments were on the record; Steve I encourage you to ask him about those days and about the French contribution to the Afghanistan mission.

Without the diplomatic, military and financial support of La France during the American rebellion - when the Americans were the insurgents against a hegemonic power - this country would not have come to be.

Many readers may remember the following day Le Monde printed "Nous sommes tous Américains!". We had no stronger allies in all the world at that time. It is deeply distressing how our own leaders have squandered the goodwill of France and the world since then.

Posted by sapeur, Aug 14 2006, 8:16AM - Link

Lonely Heart ........ wrong, on both. Especially watch C-Span tonight to see for yourself. As an American you'll either like the guy for his demeanor and sensible intellect, or you'll hate the guy for his demeanor and sensible intellect.

Posted by Houndslow, Aug 14 2006, 9:12AM - Link

Here is a good article that all you anti-Semites should enjoy, entitled:

The land of the free - but free speech is a rare commodity

You can say what you like in the US, just as long as you don't ask awkward questions about America's role in the Middle East

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,,1843543,00.html

Posted by Kathleen, Aug 14 2006, 11:54AM - Link

Well, thank goodness, some sense again. How idiotic for the US to forget our friend, France.

We need to help remind everyone and to repair our friendship and respect for France. Our most beloved national monument is Lady Liberty, but dywe've forgotten too much about it's origin and meaning.

Freedom is on the march allright, right on out of here.

French 75; 4 bottles of champagne, 1 bottle of brandy. Named after France's biggest gun, at the time.

un autre etienne, I belive you m,eant to say "meileur", not "milleur"?

Posted by Kelley, Aug 14 2006, 3:02PM - Link

To brush up, just grab your passport. La belle langue has been the 'other' language in US passports since we were founded. I recently renewed, and they have recently added Spanish. Perhaps because it's more useful in the current American mix, but knowing these clowns, I think it's probably to obscure the history between France and America. After all, what else have these Republicans ever done for the non-Cuban Spanish speakers of the U.S.?

Posted by Brian C.B., Aug 15 2006, 8:33AM - Link

Gilbert du Montier (ZHYEE-berh due MON-tee-AY), Marquis de Lafayette (mar-KEE de-la-FIE-ett) was a French aristocrat who had been orphaned at 13, signed into the army at 14, and married into a second powerful and wealthy, ancient and noble, French family at 16. He took up the American cause, against the French throne’s wish, in 1777 out of personal ambition and a desire to strike the British, who had been part of the alliance that killed his father at the Battle of Minden. By 1781, he had become a capable, 24-year-old commander of American troops, a competent speaker of English, a significant financial contributor to the United States, a favorite of George Washington, and a vigorous advocate for the Franco-American alliance. At his death in 1834 he had barely survived the French Revolution, been one of Jefferson’s closest friends, and grown into his generation’s foremost champion of liberal democracy. He met such popular adoration on his 1824 tour of the United States that he became the namesake of dozens of American counties and towns, a number that would grow to over one hundred. Today, the Stars and Stripes and the Tricolor alike adorn his tomb in eastern Paris, and an equestrian statue of the French nobleman rises from an eponymous square in front of the White House.

*Full name: Marie Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Montier, Marquis de Lafayette

Posted by JohnStuart, Aug 15 2006, 8:55AM - Link

Le Cercle Rochambeau---more apt than the le Cercle Lafayette

Steve, I welcome the French Ambassador’s initiative, but I regret that he chooses the conventional figure (the Marquis de Lafayette) as his symbol of French-American cooperation rather than the more important (but less well-known) Jean Baptiste Donaben de Vimeur, comte de Rochambeau.

Rochambeau was in many ways a “founding father” of the United States.

With the invaluable help of a combined French military force commanded by the Comte de Rochambeau, General George Washington and his Continental Army cornered and forced the surrender of a large British army under the command of Lord Cornwallis.

This defeat at Yorktown, Virginia, on October 19, 1781, forced the British to seriously negotiate for a peace and recognize American independence.

The story began when France sided with the Revolutionaries in America and Louis XVI and his minister Vergennes, wanted to limit their support to providing more naval assistance.

But by the end of 1779, the situation in the colonies had became so difficult that the King agreed to give La Fayette 5,500 men. The soldiers had been chosen from among the best regiments in the kingdom.

They were placed under the command of Rochambeau whose own son had joined the expeditionary force. They sailed for America in July 1780. Rochambeau advised Washington to attack Cornwallis in the South instead of Clinton in New York.

Washington's decision to accept the stragegic assessment of his French colleague, Rochambeau, led directly to the American victory at Yorktown.

The French government has wisely named their Lycée in Washington (actually in Bethesda) after the Comte de Rochambeau.


I my view, the new cercle should follow suit.

John Stuart

Posted by chris_from_boca, Aug 15 2006, 11:54AM - Link

oui. tres bien. may I commend to you for the location of your first retreat, my cousins' hotel on the shoreline in Cape May, NJ? The Marquis de Lafayette, of course!

Posted by donna bionda, Aug 15 2006, 2:07PM - Link

What does the Statue of Liberty and Greater Lebanon have in common?

They are both a gift from France.

Posted by Frank, Aug 15 2006, 3:41PM - Link

Goes to show the strength of puppeteer AIPAC's strings. The puppets, politicians and MSM, really are dancing to the strings pulled by AIPAC. No one should wonder about the drummed up hysteria of little pious Joe losing the primary. Israel knows some of their leverage in controlling this government will be lost if little pious Joe loses the election as an independent.

Succinctly put; a vote for Lamont is not only a vote for the fight against terrorism, but a vote against the control of our government by AIPAC's masters.

Posted by MP, Aug 16 2006, 12:57PM - Link

Frank, is history repeating itself? Here's an interesting clip from Wikipedia's post on Charles Lindbergh who was a member of the America First Committee (a group Carroll might feel comfy in):

"As World War II began in Europe, Lindbergh became a prominent speaker in favor of non-intervention, going so far as to recommend that the United States negotiate a neutrality pact with Germany during his January 23, 1941 testimony before Congress. He joined the antiwar America First Committee and soon became its most prominent public spokesman, speaking to overflow crowds in Madison Square Garden in New York City and Soldier Field in Chicago, Illinois.

Charles Lindbergh speaking at an AFC rally
In a speech at an America First rally on September 11, 1941 in Des Moines, Iowa entitled "Who Are the War Agitators?", Lindbergh claimed that three groups had been "pressing this country toward war" - the Roosevelt Administration, the British, and the Jews - and complained about what he insisted was the Jews' "large ownership and influence in our motion pictures, our press, our radio and our government." Although he made clear his opposition to German anti-Semitism, stating that "All good men of conscience must condemn the treatment of the Jews in Germany", other comments seemed to suggest that he believed that Jews should expect trouble for supporting the war: "Instead of agitating for war, the Jewish groups in this country should be opposing it in every possible way for they will be among the first to feel its consequences. Tolerance is a virtue that depends upon peace and strength. History shows that it cannot survive war and devastation."

I wonder what he meant when he said that Jews "wil be among the first to feel its consequences"? Hollywood and the media then, AIPAC today. Same shit; different bucket.

Posted by Berin Szoka, Aug 16 2006, 5:22PM - Link

Et quoi de nous qui aiment la France mais qui abhorrent la Revolution monstrueuse? Est-ce que les monarchistes sont invites bien que les Jacobins et les Girondistes?

N'oubliez pas que Lafeyette soi-meme n'etait plus qu'un Feuillant--vraiment, un monarchist constitutionel et liberale.

Vive la liberte, vive le roi. Mort a la Revolution!

Posted by xhlqoprc xvynrg, Oct 07 2006, 7:02PM - Link

cnuio lkvq puht yshfvdeu bmrwvnk wpieo kegfchzsj

Posted by uktj iuabqkod, Oct 10 2006, 2:31AM - Link

gyrb rgqijkx qatv mqrose xfnbo udhfv jzlfasdk

Posted by hoodia weight loss, Apr 01 2007, 1:38PM - Link

Hoodia Gordonii Plus is a cutting-edge, advanced appetite suppressant, metabolism booster, fat burner and energy enhancer all in one. This is a supplement if you are looking for more than just an appetite suppresent.

http://hoodia.weightloss.lt/hoodia-review.php

Posted by Sithan, Oct 22 2007, 7:13AM - Link

You can say what you like in the US, just as long as you don't ask awkward questions about America's role in the Middle East

Posted by tomka, Jun 11 2008, 5:01AM - Link

Hi! i found a lot of films here, of course if you are using rapidshare premium account http:// megauploadfiles.com

Posted by Mr. Garcia, Mar 23 2009, 5:34PM - Link

i would really like to know about Jean Baptiste Donaben de Vimeur, comte de Rochambeau because i have searched for some time and nothing is really informed me of why he was not the choosen character to represent the french as a figure of the revolution because i believe this man of importance was the cause for the american revolution who came up with the bottled up military tactic............

Leave a comment:


(required)
(required)
- only for verification, not for display or any other use.

(required)

Type the characters you see in the picture above.


The Washington Note - Steven ClemonsHome - About - Archives - Published - Recommended - Advertise - Contact
THIS SITE IS COPYRIGHT © 2010 THE WASHINGTON NOTE. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.
En ligne pas cher tadalafil 20mg acheter cialis sans ordonnance en France les informations relatives au mode d'action et les effets secondaires. Le jeu en ligne est devenu une industrie millions de dollars avec des joueurs de partout dans le monde des paris sur les jeux de casino en ligne. La gamme exclusive de jeux de casino soutenu par caractéristiques exceptionnelles et des avantages a surpassé le glamour de casinos terrestres. Même les gens qui n'ont jamais été à un casino sur terre, ou joué tout jeu de casino jamais, deviennent attirés par le monde exceptionnel de jeux en ligne. Vous pourriez vous demander ce qui rend le jeu en ligne si populaire, quand il n'y a pas de concessionnaire réel, pas de vraie foule, pas de serveuses glamour et pas de boissons gratuites. Ci-dessous sont cinq raisons fondamentales pour lesquelles un grand nombre de joueurs de casino se dirigent vers les casino en ligne aujourd'hui. Le Casino en ligne contient également un certain nombre de formateurs de jeu pour les jeux les plus populaires de casino en ligne! Vous pouvez jouer gratuitement ici sur le site et recevoir des conseils de stratégie de l'entraîneur sur le chemin. Notre dévotion au jeu en ligne nous met en mesure de vous proposer les meilleures affaires en bonus avec les meilleurs casinos en ligne. Cela signifie plus d'argent dans votre poche. Restez branchés pour les bonus de casino plus rentables et les promotions à venir.