Advertisers:
advertise on this site


Steve Clemons interviews Eli Pariser

Former Executive Director of MoveOn.org, Eli Pariser discusses his new book "The Filter Bubble" and how the architecture of the internet is evolving to match our interests and filtering out information that might challenge our opinions.

Steve Clemons on Obama's Approach to Libya

Steve Clemons argues that in addittion to being ineffectual militarily, a no-fly zone will change the narrative of the Libyan uprising and shift the focus from the decisions of the Libyan rebels to the actions of Western nations.

Ian Bremmer On the War Between States and Corporations

Eurasia Group President Ian Bremmer discusses the political and economic impacts of the economic recession, as well as rising economic powers.

More videos are available on the Video Archives Page

The Washington Note is now a member of the Political Insiders advertising network:
Find out more...

VA Loan and VA Refinance
Information from VA Mortgage Center



ADVERTISE SEND FEEDBACK OR TIPS CONTACT DETAILS
Support The Washington Note

Using PayPal

Rogoff on the Sorry State of Economic History

Share / Recommend - Comment - Print - Sunday, Apr 11 2010, 4:43AM

Former IMF Chief Economist and Harvard University economist Kenneth Rogoff made an interesting point on "economic history" at the Institute for New Economic Thinking conference.

Reflecting on a book he recently co-authored with Carmen Reinhart titled This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, Rogoff said that despite there being some superb financial scholars in the field like Barry Eichengreen, Christina Romer and others, there was just too little support for the field. He said that it was very rare to see an appointment of economic historians in university departments.

Rogoff said that in blocking the broader rooting of economic historians, "this may be an area where the inward looking nature, the triumphalism of theoretical macroeconomics, has had a little too much influence. History has had a lot to say...when we look at these very rare events [financial crises], very hard to calibrate them on normal data, even if you have the right. . .perfect model."

I think Rogoff makes an important point here -- and after much other discussion at this INET Conference -- one does sense the tendency of the economics profession to want to avoid scrutiny and historical challenge.

-- Steve Clemons

« Previous Article - Soros as Intellectual Protagonist
» Next Article - Another Hidden Cost Of the War In Afghanistan

Reader Comments (6) - post a comment

Posted by erichwwk, Apr 11 2010, 7:56PM - Link


I too lament the respect economic historians get, or more importantly, the study of economic history gets re. to econometrics.

Another very notable exception is Douglass North (winner of the 1993 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences, along with another economic historian, Robert Fogel). Robert Heilbroner and John Galbraith are two other economic historians most folk have at least heard of, before the cult of mathematical economics became the flavor of the era.

"Mathematics brought rigor to Economics. Unfortunately, it also brought mortis"

-- Kenneth Boulding


Posted by WharfRat, Apr 11 2010, 10:24PM - Link

Of course, the death of economic history can be tied
to a larger trend in the University toward research
that can secure funding from private entities. See
for example this article by Princeton's Anthony
Grafton:
http://blogs.nybooks.com/post/437005501/britain-the-
disgrace-of-the-universities

Hopefully INET is a different type of beast that
sees the value in original research that is not
immediately tied to bringing new products to market.

Posted by Kathleen, Apr 12 2010, 9:26AM - Link

Not many folks covering this. Especially our MSM (hello Rachel, Keith) enough stories about Sarah Palin
Has Aafia Siddiqui’s Daughter Surfaced?
http://emptywheel.firedoglake.com/
Last weekend a girl approximately 12 years old, who spoke only English and Persian and claimed her name was “Fatima,” was dropped off in front of the home of Siddiqui’s sister. Some stories indicate an American named “John” may have been with her. Dawn reported a senior policeman described that the girl was:

… wearing a collar “bearing the address of the house in case she wandered off”.

Posted by JohnH, Apr 12 2010, 11:18AM - Link

We miss John Kenneth Galbraith, too. He would talk about the structure of the economy and problems inherent in it, not just the horse race that most economists love to follow.

The country urgently needs to address the widespread rise of shared monopolies, not just banks that are too big to fail, and the concentration of wealth and power in the hands of a tiny elite.

"We may have democracy, or we may have wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we can't have both." - Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis

Posted by erichwwk, Apr 16 2010, 9:31AM - Link

May be talking in an abandoned closet. But...

Mark Thoma: "How Mathematics Might Have Caused the Financial Crisis"

"As we looked around to find courses to cut to make room for the new technical tools that were coming into economics, our mistake was thinking that US economic history and the history of economic thought were the least valuable courses that we offered. In fact, they may be among the most important. There’s no way to know if more attention to and knowledge of the past would have made a difference, but I think it could have, and we need to rethink the elimination of these courses from graduate studies."

http://moneywatch.bnet.com/economic-news/blog/maximum-utility/how-mathematics-might-have-caused-the-financial-crisis/577/

Posted by erichwwk, Apr 16 2010, 9:38AM - Link

While I regularly try to read Mark Thoma's column at http://economistsview.typepad.com/, I would not have caught the above without the heads-up of Daniel Mandel and Steve Clemons,the latter who pushes the former's daily selection of economics postings.

So.... thanks to both

Leave a comment:


(required)
(required)
- only for verification, not for display or any other use.

(required)

Type the characters you see in the picture above.


The Washington Note - Steven ClemonsHome - About - Archives - Published - Recommended - Advertise - Contact
THIS SITE IS COPYRIGHT © 2010 THE WASHINGTON NOTE. ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.
En ligne pas cher tadalafil 20mg acheter cialis sans ordonnance en France les informations relatives au mode d'action et les effets secondaires. Le jeu en ligne est devenu une industrie millions de dollars avec des joueurs de partout dans le monde des paris sur les jeux de casino en ligne. La gamme exclusive de jeux de casino soutenu par caractéristiques exceptionnelles et des avantages a surpassé le glamour de casinos terrestres. Même les gens qui n'ont jamais été à un casino sur terre, ou joué tout jeu de casino jamais, deviennent attirés par le monde exceptionnel de jeux en ligne. Vous pourriez vous demander ce qui rend le jeu en ligne si populaire, quand il n'y a pas de concessionnaire réel, pas de vraie foule, pas de serveuses glamour et pas de boissons gratuites. Ci-dessous sont cinq raisons fondamentales pour lesquelles un grand nombre de joueurs de casino se dirigent vers les casino en ligne aujourd'hui. Le Casino en ligne contient également un certain nombre de formateurs de jeu pour les jeux les plus populaires de casino en ligne! Vous pouvez jouer gratuitement ici sur le site et recevoir des conseils de stratégie de l'entraîneur sur le chemin. Notre dévotion au jeu en ligne nous met en mesure de vous proposer les meilleures affaires en bonus avec les meilleurs casinos en ligne. Cela signifie plus d'argent dans votre poche. Restez branchés pour les bonus de casino plus rentables et les promotions à venir.